Monthly Archives: September 2011

Unduly Suggestive Lineups: When Only The Defendant Matches A Key Aspect Of The Description

People v. Kenley 2011 NY SLip Op 06331 Appellate Division, First Department Decided August 25, 2011 Issue: Whether the lineup was unduly suggestive when only the defendant matched a key aspect of the description provided by witnesses. Holding:  A lineup … Continue reading

Posted in Identification Evidence, Identification Procedures, Lineups | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Reasonable Suspicion For The Stop and Frisk

People v. Fernandez Appellate Division, First Department 2011 NY Slip Op 06299 Decided August 18, 2011 Issue: Whether the behavior of defendant constituted reasonable suspicion for the police to stop and detain the defendant and forcibly search his person. Holding: … Continue reading

Posted in Probable Cause, Reasonable Suspicion, Stop and Frisk, Suppression | Leave a comment

Defense Counsel’s Failure to Object Constitutes Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

People v. Miller Appellate Division, Second Department 2011 NY Slip Op 06573 Decided on September 20, 2011 Issue: Whether defense counsel’s failure to object to certain prejudicial testimony that established his client’s propensity to commit the crimes charged deprived the defendant … Continue reading

Posted in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel | Leave a comment

Prosecution’s Comments on Defendant’s Post Arrest Silence Constitute Reversible Error

People v. Tucker Appellate Division, Second Department 2011 NY Slip Op 06575 Decided on September 20, 2011 Issue: Whether reference to the defendant’s post arrest silence in the prosecutor’s cross examination of defendant and during the prosecutor’s closing arguments when prosecutor stated that ”an innocent … Continue reading

Posted in Miranda Warnings, Prosecutorial Misconduct | Leave a comment