Category Archives: Discretion of Trial Court

Rules of Evidence: Defendant’s Testimony At Trial

People v. Robinson 2011 NY Slip Op 07147 Decided on October 13, 2011 Issue: Whether the trial court erred when it did not allow the defendant to testify regarding a statement that he had made to the police at the … Continue reading

Posted in Discretion of Trial Court, Evidence | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Federal Sentencing: Reduction of Sentence – Amendment 706 and District Court Discretion under § 3582 – Controlled Substances

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Appellee, – V.- LAWRENCE JOHNSON, ALBERTO FLAHARTY, also known as Enrique, also known as Rique, GARTH BRUCE, also known as G-Man, Defendants-Appellants. Decided January 28, 2011 Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

Posted in Amendment 706, Blog, Discretion of Trial Court, Federal Sentencing, Sentence, United States Sentencing Guidlines | Leave a comment

Authority Of The Trial Court To Reinstate An Indictment And Superseding Indictments

People v. Frederick New York Court of Appeals Slip Op 04874 Decided June 10, 2010 Issue : whether a trial court can reinstate an indictment for felony murder after a mistrial had been declared and the indictment dismissed pursuant to … Continue reading

Posted in Blog, Discretion of Trial Court, Indictment | Leave a comment

-Notes From The Jury During Deliberations

People v. Kadarko , New York Court of Appeals, Decided April 6, 2010 2010 NY Slip Op 02834 Notes from the jury during deliberations: does the trial court have to tell all that is in the jury’s note? Issue : … Continue reading

Posted in Blog, Discretion of Trial Court, Jury Deliberations | Leave a comment

Potential Conflicts and Trial Court’s Discretion to Disqualify Defense Counsel

PEOPLE V. CARNCROSS : New York Court of Appeals decided March 25, 2010 2010 NY Slip Op 02435, 2010 WL 1063952 Issue : Whether a trial court can disqualify defense counsel over the defendant’s objection when there is a potential … Continue reading

Posted in Blog, Discretion of Trial Court, Ineffective Assistance of Counsel, Right to Counsel | Leave a comment